Due to the town's protests, architect Nell returns home to Briar Falls for Christmas this year. After a long and historic tradition, the Playhouse will no longer host the annual Christmas tableaux. In this employment, Nell meets the new owner, Connor, whose vision and ideas collide with Nell's. In order to sway Connor's mind about upgrading the Majestic, Nell decides to give him a crash lesson in Christmas during the town's 12 Day Festival.