David Morales (Mario Lopez), an Arizona high school principal and single father, has lost his festive joy following the death of his wife during the Christmas season a few years earlier. Now, David will go to any length to avoid Christmas, including moonlighting as a delivery driver. However, this year, David's 14-year-old daughter, Noel (Paulina Chavez), and his live-in sister, Marissa (Marycarmen Lopez), are determined to restore the family's yuletide joy and, with any luck, to assist David in finding love via online dating. As a result, when Sophie (AnnaLynne McCord), a clever musician and a customer on David's delivery route, swipes right on him, something amazing occurs between them.