Waitress Annie has broken up with her alcoholic and suicidal husband, Glenn. Glenn is now an evangelical Christian, but his erratic attempts to get back into Annie's life have bothered her. This is because Glenn is now a Christian. In high school, Arthur works at Annie's restaurant after school and gets to know a new girl in town, Lila. When Glenn and Annie's daughter goes missing, the whole town looks for her as he gets more and more out of control.